Photomicrograph of red particles from a Kerala red rain sample

Kerala Red Rain: When the Sky Rained Red in 2001

by
About 4 min read

On the morning of 25 July 2001, at Morkulangara near Changanassery in Kottayam district, rain fell that was not colourless. Collected in vessels, the water was red, at times as strongly coloured as blood. Over the following weeks, similar showers were reported sporadically across the southern Indian state of Kerala, most heavily in the districts of Kottayam and Idukki, continuing intermittently until 23 September 2001. The rain stained clothes pink. People also reported yellow, green, and black rain. In a state in the middle of the monsoon, where heavy rain is a fact of life, the colour was alarming, and the explanations offered in the first days were dramatic.

Coloured rain is not new to Kerala. Similar events were reported in 1896 and several times since, including a red rain in Wayanad district on 15 July 1957, and again in June 2012. The phenomenon has a long history under the name “blood rain,” and in other parts of the world red rain is usually caused by fine desert dust carried by the wind. But the 2001 event was unusually widespread and persistent, lasting about two months, and it arrived with a detail that pointed investigators in a different direction: witnesses reported a loud sound, described as a sonic boom, shortly before the first red showers. That sound, never confirmed as a meteor, encouraged the first hypothesis.

The Meteor Idea

In the first days, scientists at the Centre for Earth Science Studies (CESS) in Thiruvananthapuram suggested that the colour might be fallout from a hypothetical meteor burst, a meteor exploding in the atmosphere and scattering debris over the region. The idea fitted the reported sound and the sudden appearance of coloured rain. Within days, however, the hypothesis began to fail. A meteor burst would scatter debris over a wide area at once, not produce sharply localised showers that came and went over two months. When the red rain continued, CESS retracted the meteor suggestion.

What the investigators found under the microscope was biological, not mineral. The red colour came from particles suspended in the rainwater, not from a dissolved dye. The brownish-red solid separated from the water consisted of about 90 percent round red particles, the rest debris. The particles were typically 4 to 10 micrometres across, spherical or oval, and present in enormous numbers: later reports put the count at about nine million particles in a single millilitre, with an estimated total of around 50,000 kilograms of red material across the event.

The Official Investigation

The Government of India’s Department of Science and Technology commissioned a joint investigation by the Centre for Earth Science Studies and the Tropical Botanical Garden and Research Institute (TBGRI). Their report, issued in November 2001, concluded that the colour was caused by a large quantity of spores of a lichen-forming alga belonging to the genus Trentepohlia. Field verification showed that the region had plenty of such lichens. Samples of lichen taken from the Changanassery area, when cultured in an algal growth medium, produced the same kind of algae as the rainwater samples, indicating that the spores in the rain most probably came from local sources.

Trentepohlia is a green alga, a chlorophyte, but it looks orange or red. The colour comes from large quantities of orange carotenoid pigments, the same family of compounds that makes carrots orange, which mask the green of the chlorophyll underneath. It grows abundantly on tree bark, damp soil, and rocks in tropical and subtropical regions, and it is also the photosynthetic partner, or photobiont, in many lichens. When the investigators revisited the site on 16 August 2001, they found that almost all the trees, rocks, and even lamp posts in the region were covered with Trentepohlia, in amounts estimated to be sufficient to generate the quantity of spores seen in the rainwater. The report found no meteoric, volcanic, or desert dust origin in the rainwater, and concluded that the colour was not due to dissolved gases or pollutants. Heavy rains in the weeks before the red rain, the report suggested, could have caused the widespread growth of lichens, producing a large quantity of spores in the atmosphere.

The Claim From Space

The Kerala red rain might have remained a local scientific curiosity had it not been for a paper published in 2006 by Godfrey Louis and A. Santhosh Kumar, physicists at Mahatma Gandhi University in Kottayam. They argued that the red particles were cells of extraterrestrial origin, possibly delivered by a comet or meteor that had disintegrated in the atmosphere over Kerala. The claim, a form of the panspermia hypothesis, the idea that life can travel between worlds, attracted international media attention. Early versions of the argument also claimed that the cells contained no DNA, a claim that was later overturned when DNA was found in the particles.

The extraterrestrial hypothesis has not survived examination. No meteor was recorded over Kerala at the time, and the isotopic ratios of nitrogen and carbon in the red material were consistent with terrestrial origins. The cells matched local algae when cultured, and the official investigation had already found the same organism growing abundantly on trees and rocks in the affected area. The sonic boom reported before the first showers was never tied to a recorded meteor event, and may have been a separate, unrelated occurrence, or a misreported sound. No evidence has established an extraterrestrial origin for the particles, and the scientific consensus remains that the colour came from local Trentepohlia spores.

What Is Documented — and What Is Not

Documented: Red rain fell sporadically in Kerala, India, from 25 July to 23 September 2001, beginning at Morkulangara near Changanassery in Kottayam district, and most heavily in Kottayam and Idukki districts. The colour came from suspended particles, about 90 percent round red particles 4 to 10 micrometres across. A joint report by the Centre for Earth Science Studies and the Tropical Botanical Garden and Research Institute, issued in November 2001, concluded that the colour was due to spores of the lichen-forming alga Trentepohlia, matched by cultures from local lichens, and found no meteoric, volcanic, or desert dust origin. Similar coloured rain had been reported in Kerala before, including in 1896 and 1957, and again in 2012.

Not documented / unverified: The early hypothesis of fallout from a meteor burst was suggested and then retracted by CESS, and no meteor was recorded. The 2006 claim by Godfrey Louis and A. Santhosh Kumar that the particles were extraterrestrial cells from a disintegrating comet has no supporting evidence; isotopic analysis supported terrestrial origins, and the early claim that the cells contained no DNA was overturned. The reported sonic boom before the first showers was never confirmed as a meteor event. Flagged as unverified: the species-level identification as Trentepohlia annulata comes from a 2015 study and is often presented as final, but the 2001 investigation itself identified the genus Trentepohlia; the exact mechanism by which such large numbers of spores entered the atmosphere was not fully established by the official report, which called the local origin “most probable” rather than proven.

Sources

Leave a Comment