The Lost Dutchman Mine: Gold, Death, and the Superstition Mountains

The Superstition Mountains of Arizona from the Dutchman's Trail, with Weaver's Needle — the landmark in Jacob Waltz's deathbed directions — at right

About 4 min readJacob Waltz died in Phoenix in 1891, leaving a trunk of rich gold ore and a set of deathbed directions centred on Weaver’s Needle. Generations of searchers have followed them into the Superstition Mountains — dozens never came back, and no mine has ever been found. Was Waltz guarding a real mine, or only the gold he took from somewhere else?

The Lost City of Atlantis: Plato’s Story and the Search for a Sunken World

An aerial view of the Santorini caldera — the flooded volcanic crater at the heart of the leading theory that the Bronze Age eruption of Thera inspired Plato's Atlantis

About 4 min readPlato described a great island empire that sank beneath the waves — and in 2,400 years, no one has found a trace of it beyond his two dialogues. Santorini, the Sahara, the Azores and Antarctica have all been proposed; every candidate has failed. Why does a story with a single source still launch expeditions?

The Honey Island Swamp Monster: Louisiana’s Seven-Foot Swamp Ape

An alligator swimming in the murky, reed-fringed water of Honey Island Swamp, Louisiana — a real resident of the swamp, not the monster itself

About 4 min readIn 1963, a retired air traffic controller named Harlan Ford reported a seven-foot, grey-haired creature with yellow eyes in the Honey Island Swamp — and plaster casts of footprints no known animal could have made. Sixty years on, the swamp still keeps its secret.

Moundsville Penitentiary: The Haunted Prison on the Hill

The West Virginia State Penitentiary in Moundsville, West Virginia

About 5 min readFor 119 years, the West Virginia State Penitentiary at Moundsville was one of the most violent prisons in America — 94 executions, 36 murders, and cells five feet by seven. It closed in 1995. The ghost hunters arrived almost immediately.

Bachelors Grove Cemetery: The Madonna, the Phantom House, and Chicago’s Most Haunted Acre

The overgrown entrance trail to Bachelors Grove Cemetery in Midlothian, Illinois, in 2008

About 4 min readHidden in the woods southwest of Chicago, a one-acre cemetery closed to burials in 1965 has produced more than a hundred reported encounters — a translucent woman photographed in 1991, a farmhouse that appears and vanishes, and a pond said to hide mob victims.

Bessie, the Lake Erie Monster: Two Centuries of Serpents in the Inland Sea

A sailboat at sunrise on Lake Erie, seen from Sandusky, Ohio, with a motorboat and a distant light on the horizon — the waters where Bessie is said to swim

About 4 min readFor more than two hundred years, sailors and fishermen on Lake Erie have reported a long, dark, serpentine creature, thirty to forty feet long, sliding through the water off Sandusky Bay. No body, photograph, or DNA sample has ever confirmed it — and the reports have never stopped.

Bobby Mackey’s Music World: The Haunted Honky-Tonk of Wilder, Kentucky

Bobby Mackey's Music World in Wilder, Kentucky, photographed in 2016 before the building was demolished in 2024

About 5 min readFor nearly half a century, Bobby Mackey’s Music World offered country music upstairs and ghost stories downstairs — a basement well, a murdered woman, and a sign at the door warning that the place was haunted. In December 2024, the building was demolished.